I am using joi-browser 13.4.0. In order to generate error message for each input field I am trying to validate fields using .required() like so:

  config = {
    input1: Joi.string()
      .empty("")
      .required(),
    input2: Joi.string()
      .empty("")
      .required()
  };

  schema = Joi.object(this.config).xor("input1", "input2");

But this example is invalid because when input1 or input2 is set to .required(), .xor() function is being ignored. Is there any other way to implement XOR validation without using .xor() method?

Thanks.

I am using joi-browser 13.4.0. In order to generate error message for each input field I am trying to validate fields using .required() like so:

  config = {
    input1: Joi.string()
      .empty("")
      .required(),
    input2: Joi.string()
      .empty("")
      .required()
  };

  schema = Joi.object(this.config).xor("input1", "input2");

But this example is invalid because when input1 or input2 is set to .required(), .xor() function is being ignored. Is there any other way to implement XOR validation without using .xor() method?

Thanks.

• javascript
• validation
• joi

Share Improve this question Follow asked Sep 24, 2019 at 22:34 TwistedOwlTwistedOwl 1,32422 gold badges1818 silver badges3333 bronze badges

Add a ment  | 

2 Answers 2

Sorted by: Reset to default 6

You don't need required() if you're using xor:

config = {
  input1: Joi.string().empty(""),
  input2: Joi.string().empty("")
};

schema = Joi.object(config).xor("input1", "input2");

In fact, using required() like that would never validate. You'd get one of the following error messages:

ValidationError: child "input1" fails because ["input1" is required]

or

ValidationError: "value" contains a conflict between exclusive peers [input1, input2]

Use object.length()

Is there any other way to implement XOR validation without using .xor() method?

Yes, you could for example use the object().length() property to limit the keys in an object to 1.

const Joi = require('joi-browser')

const schema = Joi.object().keys({
  input1: Joi.string().empty(''),
  input2: Joi.string().empty('')
}).required().length(1);

const value = {
  input1: "input1",
};

// this will fail
// const value = {};

// this will fail too
// const value = {
//   input1: 'input1',
//   input2: 'input2',
// };

const result = Joi.validate(value, schema);
console.log(JSON.stringify(result.error, null, 2));

Be careful

Don't forget to add required() to the parent object, otherwise it is possible to pass undefined to the validation function!

Without required() on the parent it is possible that a simple undefined will pass the validation:

const Joi = require('joi-browser')

const schema = Joi.object().keys({
  input1: Joi.string().empty(''),
  input2: Joi.string().empty('')
}).length(1); // no required()

const value = undefined; // this will pass validation

const result = Joi.validate(value, schema);
console.log(JSON.stringify(result.error, null, 2));